Authenticity Is Our Specialty

Dig into some authentic Italian food here in Toms River, NJ

When you're in the mood for authentic Italian food, it's time to stop by Anthony's From Brooklyn in Toms River, NJ. At our local deli, we serve top-notch and totally fresh Italian sandwiches served on New York bread baked fresh daily. These include our delectable breakfast sandwiches, which serve as an excellent way to start anyone's day.

Of course, we can't forget about our handmade New York style-pizza. Save yourself a trip into the city by placing your pizza order with us instead! Call in and check back for homemade weekly specials that are not listed on the menu.

Contact us today to learn more about our authentic Italian food.

What sets our deli apart?

Ever since he was a kid growing up on Bay 13th & 86th street, the founder Anthony has always dreamed of opening a deli. With his parents hailing straight from Italy, Anthony aims to bring that heritage to the forefront of every dish served. You can even find his mom helping out in the kitchen for that extra level of authenticity!

You'll love our local deli as we:

  • Are family owned and operated
  • Have a wide selection of menu items
  • Use premium Boar's Head meats
  • Have a friendly staff and atmosphere
  • Offer convenient online ordering

Stop by today to taste for yourself what makes us so unique!

Catering made easy

Looking for help catering an event? We have your back.
We can cater just about any kind of event, no matter the size. That way, you won't have to worry about preparing all the food yourself.